Not Broken
Short Film
How Not Broken Came To Be
June 24, 2026
Not Broken started as a homework assignment.
In 2025, I enrolled in a playwriting course at the University of Toronto. For our final assignment, we were asked to write a ten-minute scene. Around the same time, I was also developing my musical My Gulabi Baby, so I was spending a lot of time thinking about character, dialogue, and how tension can be built through conversation alone.
The scene I wrote was simple: a queer South Asian son sits down with his mother and tells her something he’s been carrying for a long time.
When the course ended, I couldn’t stop thinking about it.
There was something about the simplicity of the scene that stayed with me. No big plot twists. No elaborate setting. Just two people trying to navigate a difficult conversation.
The more I revisited it, the more I felt there was a short film hidden inside it.
As someone who grew up in a South Asian Muslim household, I found myself drawing from emotions and memories I understood well. Not specific events, but the feeling of rehearsing conversations in your head before they happen. Wondering how someone will react. Imagining every possible outcome.
I remember my own coming out experience feeling strangely isolated. Not because I was alone, but because everything else seemed to disappear for a moment. It was as if the room got smaller and all that existed was the conversation in front of me.
That feeling became the foundation for the film.
From the beginning, I knew I wanted the visual approach to be minimal. My love of theatre had a big influence on the project. On stage, there is nowhere to hide. The audience is focused entirely on the actors, the dialogue, and the emotional shifts happening between them.
I wanted Not Broken to have that same intimacy.
The film takes place almost entirely in a single location with very few distractions. Every creative decision was made to keep the focus on the characters and the space between them.
What started as a ten-minute classroom assignment eventually became a project I carried from script to screen. As someone new to filmmaking, I took on writing, producing, directing, and guiding it through post-production as a way to learn every part of the process. It became an opportunity to challenge myself outside of marketing and branding and explore storytelling through performance and narrative.
Starring:
Amit Mohan
Mariam Magsi
Directed & Produced by
Ali Naqi
Associate Producer
Dila Dokuzoğlu
Director of Photography
Issa Shah
Editor
Mitch Reed
Production Designer
Josette Joseph
1st Assistant Director
Dila Dokuzoğlu
1st AC
Johana Rosaly Sanchez Abed
2nd AC / DIT
Fely Fang Gao
Sound Mixer
Keth Sivakumar
Boom Operator
Lydia Shimens
Key Grip
Jane Lukashova
Gaffer
Dany Oh
Hair & Makeup
Binndi Suvarna
Production Assistant
Melisa Altuğ
Bansuri:
Hasheel
Music
Lady Pista